Quarterly Meeting Minutes, November 20, 2025
Minutes for the meeting on . Approved at the meeting on .
- Date: Thursday, November 20, 2025
- Time: 9:45 AM
- Location: Large conference room, Hub Coworking Hawaii 1050 Queen St #100, Honolulu HI 96814, - Hybrid Zoom
I. Call to Order –Donald Sakamoto
The meeting was called to order at 9:45 A.M.
Invocation given by President Sakamoto.
Opening remarks
Amanda Lowe read the housekeeping rules, disclaimer, and testimony procedures.
II. Roll Call & Introductions
In-Person Attendees:
- Donald Sakamoto (President CFADAR;
- Amanda Lowe Executive Director Statewide Independent Living Council of Hawaii (SILC);
- Patrick Gartside Chair (SILC);
- Eileen Mark Department of Transportation Services (DTS) Mass Transit Administrator (DTS);
- Stephen Nieves, Acting Skyline Rail Chief/ Operations Compliance Officer (DTS);
- Sean Pile, Vice-President of Oahu Transit Services, Inc. (OTS) Transportation TheBus;
- Tracie Coelho Vice-President (OTS) Paratransit TheHandi-Van;
- Kapono Foster (OTS) Paratransit Handi-Van (;
- Gail Faligan, Handi-Van rider;
- Isaac Lau Handi-Van rider;
- Norvin Lau.
Online Attendees:
- Ann Chipchase Hawaii Disability Rights Center;
- Kaili Swan;
- Gabrielle Soderholm of Soderholm Sales and Leasing, Inc;
- Hawaii News Now;
- Kathy Oshiro;
- Kelly Anaya, Staff member for Honolulu Councilmember Matt Wier;
- Letha DeCaires Director of Civil Rights (OTS);
- Marcel Hornor Civil Beat Reporter;
- Michelle Kennedy Vice-President, Customer Services (OTS);
- Robin Hensky staff member of Councilmember Tyler Dos Santos-Tam;
- Shannan Tsbaki.;
- Yoko Loyd Planner IV (DTS);
- Bryan Mick Disability Communication Access Board (DCAB);
- Kā’eo Kealoha-Lindsey of Councilmember Augie Tulba;
- Stanly Young transit rider.
Note: Name was not included if not legible or audible.
III. Last meeting minutes of August 21, 2025, was approved with following corrections:
- Kaili Swan requested a spelling correction for his first name.
- Donald Sakamoto corrected “Station Operator” to “Station Attendant” regarding the Skyline discussion.
Approval: The minutes were approved as amended
IV. President Report
A. Donald Sakamoto
-
On September 3, 2025 TheHandi-Van experienced a phone outage from 10:40 AM through the late evening of 9:30 PM; During the outage there was a poor communication notice to the public, and had to contact DTS who provided backup number (808) 768-8300 however, monitoring was inconsistent; A press release was finally issued by DTS at 2:48 PM however, media outlets were not properly notified earlier; There is a need for improved emergency communication protocols that needs to be in place.
-
On Sept 3, 2025 had the opportunity to attend a virtual meeting for the O’ahu Metropolitan Planning Organization (OMPO), and some of the topics that were Discussed was having green electric vehicles and with the Hawaii state 2030 emission goals/mandates.
-
On Sept 11, 2025 at 6:00 PM was able to attend an in person Town Hall meeting at Kalakaua Middle School cafeteria regarding with the Kalihi Kapālama design of the rail station with Honolulu HART Authority for Rapid Transportation (HART) representatives: Topic that was brought-up by a blind woman resident at the meeting was safety/Americans with Disability ADA access for the sidewalks along the Dillingham boulevard construction project.
-
On Sept 23, 2025, Had the opportunity to attend via zoom the city council budget committee meeting to testify on Bill 54 (2025) regarding with the fare fee hike increases for TheBus – TheHandi-Van; Was able to submit oral testimony not in favor of having Personal Care Attendants (PCA) to pay full fair when assisting a disabled rider aboard TheBus/Skyline.
-
On September 24, 2025 I had the opportunity to attend via zoom the city council Committee on Infrastructure, Transportation & Technology regarding with Bill 60 (2025) to allow HART to extend the rail Skyline all the way to Ala Moana Shopping Center and UH campus; Submitted oral testimony to oppose in passing this bill due to the ADA Title II violations being done by HART and the vendor Nan corporation who is violating the access way for sidewalks along the Dillingham boulevard corridor project.
-
On October 15, 2025, had the opportunity to attend the 2nd Segment opening of Skyline. And noticed the lack of no escalators available at the Middle Street station; News media reported that signs were posted that the elevators were out of service, and due to high volume use by riders and a communication issue between the elevator vendor company not informing the Hitachi representatives to remove the signs.
Q&A / Discussion:
- Kaili Swan raised the following concern: Regarding with Bill 54 he expressed that as a rider who uses both TheBus and Skyline it is unfair for PCA’s to have to pay for full fare when they are assisting the disabled riders; Another concern is when the elevators are out of service at the Skyline station he is afraid of coming down the steep stairs; He expressed that he loves the smooth ride on the rail cars, and that it can travel at speeds of 55 mph without any problems.
A. Skyline rail report, Steven Nieves of DTS
-
The 2nd segment of Skyline Opened on Thursday, October 16, 2025; During the opening they encountered elevator outages due to high volume due to 39,000 riders for the first weekend.
-
The performance of the Skyline system availability is 99.33% for the last 6 months and 99.46% year-to-date.
-
The daily Ridership increased from 4,500 to 10,500–11,500.
-
There was some confusion with the elevator service contractor and Hitachi regarding taking down the out of service signs at the elevators after they were repaired.
-
Ridership is doing well at the lagoon and airport stations.
-
The West Loch parking lot for the University of Hawaii (UH) Leeward Community College is running full; the riders are encouraged to use the West Oahu Halaulani parking lot across the highway from the campus.
-
Service hours of operations have been extended from 4:00 AM – 10:30 PM; The system will be operating on every 10-minute during peak hours and 15-minute on off-peak/late hours.
Q&A / Discussion:
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: If someone either falls or jumps on the rail tracks that have 750 volts what precautions are in place to insure in stopping the rail car?
-
Steven Nieves response: There are safety detection protocol systems in place if someone would have climbed over the protective screen gates at the rail station platforms an alarm would immediately go off to alert someone in the control room to stop the rail car or cut the power to the tracks; There are emergency blue lights located at each end of the stations platforms to stop the rail cars as well.
-
Kaili Swan asked the following: He commented that in Japan the attendant’s would attempt to push passengers into the rail car to close the doors, and asked what protocols are in place to close the doors if this situation would occur?
-
Steven Nieves response: If this situation occurred, they could add more rail cars to the line to compensate.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: What about access to restrooms at the rail stations?
-
Steven Nieves response: The restrooms remain locked for safety/hygiene and must be opened by an attendant.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: What does the acronym OCC mean? And at the last CFADAR meeting of August 21, 2025, in your report you stated that when the 2nd phase of Skyline is open that there will be more attendant’s available at the stations. Can you give an update about this?
-
Steven Nieves response: Occ means Operations Control Center, and as for additional attendants will be provided at seven of the stations by Hitachi however he does not have that information right now.
-
Kathy Oshiro raised the following: What protocols are in place when the elevators are not working, and how would the person in a wheelchair be taken up or down?
-
Steven Nieves response: There are protocols in place for these situations such as having an accessible ADA van vehicle available to take the rider from another station to be transported back to the other station.
-
Kathy Oshiro raised the following: When you enter the rail car door there is a Handi-Cap area behind the bench seat where Handi-Cap persons are able to sit/or wait with their wheelchair however, there are times when other people would be occupying that area, and the person in the wheelchair now has to wait in the middle of the aisle way causing a safety issue of blocking the ; What efforts can be made to address this situation?
-
Steven Nieves response: in this situation you can notify the attendant or operator either before boarding or on the train to assist in providing another Handi-Cap area in one of the other three rail cars.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: She sent an email to Mr. Sakamoto, DTS and OTS representatives regarding questions such as the opening of the restrooms at the stations that poses a health issue when you cannot find an attendant to assist in opening them, and according to the person at DTS they forwarded the email to you; Have you received the email?
-
Steven Nieves response: Yes, he has received the email with the questions and that a crafted response was made and that his director is still reviewing it, and once it is approved it will be presented to you at the next CFADAR committee meeting.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: At the last CFADAR August meeting it was reported that the 2nd segment of Skyline would have additional attendants to open the restrooms, and that one of her questions was that it is a health issue if you can’t open the door or find an attendant to assist; Does the Skyline employees have their own restrooms?
-
Steven Nieves response: Yes, the employees of OTS and Skyline are allowed to use these restrooms at the stations, and they have keys to access them.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following At a previous CFADAR meeting DTS Director Roger Morton stated that City and County employees can ride TheBus and Skyline for free for a one year project, and at the August CFADAR meeting you stated that it was extended for another year; When she asked Director Morton at the previous CFADAR meeting of May 9th if the general public was notified about this through the newspaper or media release on where it is stated that the city and county employees could ride Skyline for free; When was the start-up date and the extending date of the program? How much revenue is being loss from not collecting fares from the city employees?
-
Steven Nieves response: Those questions that you are asking will be sent to you in your letter response.
-
Norvin Lau raised the following: He mentioned that so much emphasis is being discussed about having attendants to open the restroom doors at the stations, and remarked that when you go to a public establishment area the restroom doors aren’t locked.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: Commented that when the 1st rai segment was opened the news media reported that the vending machines that sells the HOLO cards has braille however, the machines were quite low to access; There is a blind vendor who works at the Honolulu airport who contacted him regarding with the following concerns: When he takes Skyline from the Middle Street station and gets dropped off at the airport station there is really no one to assist you on where to go to the airport as well as providing any signage (audible) explaining where to go, and what efforts can be made to address this matter?; Another rider who is in a wheelchair contacted him to inform that the tap machine to enter the rail door is quite high for her to reach, and what efforts can be made to address this matter
-
Steven Nieves response: Regarding signage being provided on where to go at the airport station they are working together with DTS and State Department of Transportation (DOT) airport representatives on this matter, and hopefully by next year will have proper signage such as some type of audio to accommodate for the blind.
B. Department of Transportation Services (DTS) Updates by Eileen Mark
-
Eileen Mark: Bill 54 (2025 fare increases is still in city council committee, and DTS and the city’s administration submitted first draft of the bill; Their intent was to streamline the fares, because there were many categories of fares such as special needs groups that received services for different fare rates, and for all those riders who qualify under the special needs rider would be offered the same rate if they were under Medicare, senior citizen, low income or disabled; There are still more aspects to be discussed regarding with the bill with the city council, and to review different amendments to it before proceeding in passing it through.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: He testified at the city council committee meeting against Bill 54, because he is against charging fares for his PCA who assist him on TheBus- Skyline.
-
Eileen Mark response: Mention that you can still submit again oral and written testimony at the city council committee meetings regarding with your concerns with Bill 54 against having PCA’s paying full fares, and you can also contact and write to your councilmember in your district to voice your concerns about this as well.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: Mr. Sakamoto what is your position regarding with Bill 54?
-
Donald Sakamoto response: Like you my big concern with the bill was the fare charge for PCA’s.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following to Ms. Marks: She has been sending numerous emails to DTS and OTS representatives regarding with recommendations, complaints, compliments, and wasn’t too sure if you were forwarded with these emails to review.
-
Stanley Young raised the following: He is a blind vendor who works at the Honolulu airport, and he and other riders as well are having difficulties traversing from the airport Skyline station to the airport; No signage to direct you to the airport and It is also so confusing to catch four elevators to get down to the parking garage then trying to find your way towards the terminal; At times there is no one at the airport station to assist him, and is lucky to depend on other riders that would assist him; He said that whoever was the central planner who designed the station they really didn’t take in consideration of the consumer or user; He said point of view; Need to have ½ dozen employees to direct the riders; If a sighted rider is confused on where to go then how can a blind rider find her/his way.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: Does DTS collaborate with the neighbor island county transportation agencies to inquire on how they are handling their bus and paratransit services, and to compare/share information as well?
-
Eileen Mark response: Yes, they actually due collaborate with the neighbor islands; They had a statewide meeting two weeks ago that involved all the neighbor island county agencies that consisted engineers, planners, and Oahu MPO as well.
-
The city council is considering to have resolution 262 Repealing the Policy to remove the Farebox Recovery Ratio for the city bus system, and that DTS is annually providing information to the council to assist them with the calculated estimates of the total expenses and revenues for operations of TheBus; For a couple of years now the guideline revenue ratio that the city is required to follow is well below its margin.
-
The FTA ADA Handi-Van paratransit review is still going through with the preliminary findings from the February site visit was received two weeks ago; DTS is correcting factual errors of the review before the final report is release by the FTA.
-
Gabrielle Soderholm provided an update status regarding with the procurement of new Ford Sunset van vehicles in which the first pilot vehicle review is finally completed, and that the production of the next 17 vehicles is expected to begin arriving in January 2026;The configuration of the new layout for the vans includes a side entry rear stairway /side lift with more lighting and 3 double fold away seat, and 1 single seat that can accommodate up to 3 wheelchairs although 2 is more practical.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: How many passengers can this van accommodate?
-
Gabrielle Soderholm response: If all the seats are down in the rear of the van you can seat 7 people, and one more at the front seat near the driver for a total of 8 as well as up to 3 wheelchairs depending on how OTS Handi-Van would position their configuration of the seats.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: He had concerns about the lack of handrails on the rear side step door when coming down the stairs.
-
Gabrielle Solderholm response: She explained that a hand railing would be difficult to be mounted inside the door leaf of the frame, because the railing would prevent the narrowing of the entry width of the stairway to 27 inches.
-
Regarding Ala Moana curb cuts, DTS noted that there are private property constraints, but OTS Handi-Van operations has adjusted the drop-off points for their vans closer to Kona Street.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: She has been sending emails and has brought-up this concern with the ala Moana drop-off and pick-up location at pervious CFADAR meetings regarding how difficult it is for someone in a wheelchair or motorized scooter can’t be dropped-up or pick-up with the Ford Transit Sunset rear lift van vehicle because there are no curb cuts near this location posing a safety issue; She Witness a firsthand experience of a woman rider being dropped-off in a wheelchair in which the Handi-Van operator who was assigned a 2400 series van with the rear lift, and when the operator tried to lift the wheelchair to the top of the curb where he was experiencing a difficult time doing it, which poses a safety issue; Another incident that she witness at this location was a 2400 series van assigned to pick-up a woman in a scooter and that when she went down the curb that the scooter either would have fallen or been damaged due to the drop on the street level.
-
Eileen Marks response: DTS IS not involved in assigned to do the drop-up and pick-ups, and it is the responsibility of OTS Handi-Van operations to assigned the proper van vehicle for this location.
-
Tracie Coelho response: OTS Handi-Van has sent out a memo to all of their operators that when they are dropping-off or picking-off riders in a wheelchair or scooter at this location with a 2400 series van that they need to drive a little farther away to a curb cut.
-
Eileen Mark: As for an update regarding with the revision of TheHandi-Van riders guide there are a lot of facts involved before it can be revised, and really can’t provide any timeline right now.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: In the past DTS held in person meeting at the Mission Memorial building to receive testimonies from riders regarding with the proposed revision of the Handi-Van riders guide book.
-
Eileen Mark response: She would have to confirm with staff about this, and report back to you.
C. TheBus Report by Sean Pile, OTS
at this location was a 2400 series van assigned to pick-up a woman in a scooter and that when she went down the curb that the scooter either would have fallen or been damaged due to the drop on the street level.
-
The average weekly ridership for September 2025 was 135,356 up 2% from previous year.
-
On-Time system-wide Performance was 69.3%.
-
Update of routes: The route 671 is back on regular route.
-
New Routes: Line A (City Express), Line U (University), Line W (Waikiki).
- Route 20 and 303 discontinued; Route 42 extended to service the airport late-night.
-
Google Maps: OTS is working with “Swiftly” to push detour updates to Google Maps in Real-Time.
Q and A:/Discussion:
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: Do you have to have a military ID card when accessing the Hickam/Pearl Harbor base using the PAGE bus route? He uses google maps a lot, and inquired if there can be more information 24 hours to be provided on it? For example, to provide traffic updates of accidents.
-
Sean Pile response: Yes, you need to have a military ID card to enter the, base gates, and you don’t need military ID to board TheBus; As for providing more information on them google maps they are working with a company called Sisly who is providing detours to their google maps.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: Can there be more bus 41 and 47 routes to be added to go to the Skyline station? Can there be more bus routes added in Eva Beach to go to the Skyline station?
-
Sean Pile response: We do have a weekly meeting with DTS, and he will bring up your bus route suggestions to the committee.
-
Kathy Oshiro raised the following: Expressed her concern that when she was aboard the Ford Transit Sunset rear lift Handi-Van vehicle that she had to disembark herself on her power scooter on to the street which is dangerous to wait to allow another person to axis the lift; Had issues in going back into the van because the area is quite confined to turn in; Is there another way to handle these types of situations to make it safer?
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: Is there any bus routes going to the airport station after it is closed at 10:30 PM?
-
Sean Pile response: There was a public comment made about this, and the 42 bus route was extended to service the airport station for the later evenings.
-
Regarding with the contract negotiation between the OTS and the Teamsters union the last offer was given to them at a meeting on October 31, and the union held meetings a week ago with the members of TheBus at the Middle Street and Pearl City yards.
-
Donald Sakamoto asked on how the CFADAR quarterly meeting notices can be posted on TheBus and TheHandi-Van to inform the riders about these meetings?
-
Michelle Kennedy response: that they can provide flyers however, I would defer that question to Tracie Coelho on how they can post the flyers on the limited space on TheHandi-Van; If you wish to post them on TheBus you would need to speak to DTS.
D. TheHandi-Van Report by Tracie Coelho, OTS
-
The weekday ridership for October was 3,449 and the combined in-house and supplemental was up 3.5%.
-
On-time performance of pickups were 85.47%.
-
The excessive trip times was 10.91% of trips over 1 hour were >15 minutes longer than the fixed-bus route comparison.
-
-
The call center was 92% of calls answered within 3 minutes.
Q and A:
-
Isaac Lau reported a 2-hour wait for a Handi-Van ride home.
-
Norman Lau commented that his son and others who ride TheHandi-Van for this month had two rides that were more than an hour long in picking them up from their destination to bring them home; He called and spoke to Kapono Foster the other day about this however, he hasn’t received any call back yet; Yesterday, the kids were stuck for more than two hours from being pick-up, and called and spoke to Wayne at dispatch to inquire what was happening, and the response was that they don’t have enough employees to do everything; He expressed that it is ridiculous that his son and the other kids make their reservations ahead of time, but they keep only getting pick-up late; His son Isaac is willing to come down to TheHandi-Van offices to help with the situation.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: Expressed that she has sent numerous email to Tracie Coelho and DTS staff informing the same type of situations like the Lau’s are experiencing; She has called and booked her rides three days in advance and can’t get the hours to book her ride due to the new Real Time Pass scheduling as well as not being picked-up on time; She sent numerous emails with recommendations to OTS and DTS representatives to resolve the issues; She indicated that she has been waiting over 60 days for a response to her question on what is the ratio of Handi-Vans to eligible Handi-Van -Van riders?; And has it increase over the years?;As more people who become elderly/disabled that can’t drive anymore that the city is prepared to have enough Handi-Van vehicles available to accommodate these riders? When are you going to retire the 1400 series vans from your fleet, and auction them off; She was told last year that the 1400 series vans were going to be retired.
-
Tracie Coelho reported the following: OTS has reintroduced the Trapeze Real Time PASS Live scheduling system due to increased volume of riders; Before COVID they had this system in place in 2014 however, when COVID occurred and the ridership dropped dramatically they had to switch their booking of rides to a Matrix Scheduling system that consisted of rides scheduled on the hour or half an hour; Since COVID ended their ridership has grown to more than 4,000, and that with the high volume they couldn’t do manual scheduling anymore; When you would call in for your reservations The Pass system will now look for your requested time by availability of a van in your area. For example, if you wanted an 8:00 AM pick-up time you may get an 8:17 AM or a 7:41 AM, because the system is looking for booking of runs for that area then it would plug in your times that are available.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: Is this Real Time Trapeze Pass system being reintroduced to eventually do online scheduling due to the U. S. Department of Justice (DOJ)agreement settlement for the long wait times on your folk’s phone lines.
-
Tracie Coelho response: Yes, that was part of the reason why they are planning to introduce a scheduling website in the future to have riders to schedule their rides online.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following: He stated that TheHandi-Van total fleet is at 218 however, there are only 169 van vehicles that are in working condition, and not too sure when DTS will auction off these broken /older vans though.
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: Can the 5 minutes for TheHandi-Van waiting time for the riders could be changed to 10 possibilities in the future?
-
Tracie Coelho response: It could be a possibility however, right now it is not feasible.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: She stated difficulties booking specific times with the reservationist for an 8:30 AM pick-up was unavailable, and was offered an 8:29 AM instead.
-
Tracie Coelho: Regarding with the phone outage of October 10, 2025 there was a flooding in one of the water main drains on Middle Street that took out their entire phone system from 7:30 AM and was restored on Sunday, October 12, at 9:30 PM; the city did a public press release on that day of the outage that listed a back-up phone number to call for your reservations; Also, OTS listed the phone number on their website thebus.org.
-
Donald Sakamoto raised the following :He recommended that OTS invest to purchase a Star Link satellite system to avoid another outage
-
Kathy Oshiro raised the following: Since the Real Time Pass schedule system is in place does she need to book her rides from 2 hours to 3 hours, because she has noticed that when she does a 2 hour booking, she would arrive late to her destination.
-
Tracie Coelho response: We don’t do same day reservations, only 1, 2, and 3 days in advance; We are happy to work with you on your drop-off and pick-up times; If you are put down as a no show, can you can call our customer service delivery to explain your situation to have it cleared from your record.
IV. Public Testimony
-
Kaili Swan raised the following: He supports the procurement of new van vehicle fleet.
-
Gail Faligan raised the following: She has sent emails to Mr. Sakamoto and both OTS and DTS representatives regarding with the concerns with the rear lift vans not providing enough room for luggage/carts occupying wheelchair spaces in these vans, and requested consideration for space management before a van is sent out; Does your operators give you feedback regarding with the vans?; Expressed her concerns that The rear lift vans are really dangerous.
Donald Sakamoto thanked DTS, OTS representatives, Amanda Lowe, Patrick Gartside, and all of the public who attended the meeting this morning.
V. Adjournment
-
The meeting adjourned at approximately 11:50 A.M.
-
Next Meeting: Scheduled for February 19, 2026. Location to be determined at a later time.
Meeting minutes prepared by Donald Sakamoto