Quarterly Meeting Minutes, May 9, 2025

Minutes for the meeting on . Approved at the meeting on .

  • Date: Friday, May 9, 2025
  • Time: 9:45 AM
  • Location: Large conference room, Hub Coworking Hawaii, 1050 Queen St #100, Honolulu HI 96814

Participants attended both in-person and remotely

In person attendees:

  • Donald Sakamoto President, Citizens for a Fair Americans with Disabilities Act Ride (CFADAR);
  • Patrick Gartside, Chair of Hawaii Statewide Independent Living Council of Hawaii (SILC);
  • Roger J. Morton Director, Karisha Lawas Planner Vi, Marisa Ideta Planner VI, and Gerald Hieda Chief Facilities & Equipment Branch Department of Transportation Services (DTS);
  • Jenny Lemaota Senior Vice President, Sean BENNETT Paio, Vice-President;
  • Letha Decaires Director of Civil Rights;
  • Tracie Coelho Vice-President Paratransit Handi-Van, Francis “Kapono” Foster Director of Operations Oahu Transit Services (OTS);
  • Eric Soderholm, Vice-President of Soderholm Sales and Leasing Inc.;
  • Gail Faligan, Handi-Van rider;
  • Kathy Oshiro, Handi-Van Rider;
  • Ms. Georgina Spencer and Donna Kapuha volunteers: Guest online: Rosemary Leyson Handi-Van rider, and others.

Meeting called to order by Donald Sakamoto : 9:45 AM

Welcoming Remarks / SHORT Invocation; This is the first meeting since February 13, 2020, due to COVID-19; Housekeeping rules: Please kindly set your phones on mute/silent mode; Testimony will be limited to 3 minutes per person; Please Raise your hand to speak (via computer or by pressing *9 on your phone, and *6 to unmute); Please state your full name clearly when recognized- each time speaking, and for presenters to also please do the same before speaking for those who are deaf or hard of hearing who are viewing by closed captioning; Kindly please describe your visual presentations for those who are blind; Presentations will be limited to 3 minutes per agenda item.

President’s Report

Disclaimer: The CFADAR disclaimer was read by Eric Soderholm (see attach).

D. Sakamoto gave the following history of CFADAR: The group was first established in 2002 by Morris Nakamura a disabled bus rider who used a electric wheelchair ; Officially became CFADAR trademark (Citizens for Fair ADA Ride) in 2006, led by then chair Louise Horio a blind school teacher who was a long time rider and advocate of TheHandi-Van, and she passed away on July 26, 2012 on the same day that the Americans with Disability Act (ADA) was signed into law by President George H. W. Bush over 34 some years; Sakamoto joined the group in November 2009 and took over as chairperson around 2011 and became the president in 2015; Advocacy Work: Attended numerous Honolulu City Council meetings such as budget, transportation, and with the Honolulu Rate Commission meetings to submit oral and written testimonies; Collaborated with Erik Soderholm regarding on paratransit small bus knowledge and vehicle design construction; Filed a Civil Rights Justice Department (DOJ) complaint in August of 2019 regarding the Honolulu City’s Department of Transportation and Oahu Transit Services Handi-Van phone lines system, which was resolved in January 2023, resulting with the improvement of the phone service; Received an award from the full Honolulu City Council on February 19, 2020, for his advocacy work; CFADAR’s responsibility includes the rail (Skyline), TheBus, and TheHandi-Van.

Department of Transportation Services (DTS) Reports:

K. Lawas reported the following: Skyline Ridership: Average daily ridership (July 1, 2023 - May 1, 2025): 3,216; Average daily ridership (Jan 2024 - Dec 31, 2024): 3,145; Average daily ridership (Jan 2025 - May 1, 2025): 3,312; Total service trips: 2,157,764; Skyline performance and future plans: Segment 2 (to the airport, Lagoon Drive, and Middle Street transit center) is about 5 months from opening; On-time performance for Skyline is exceptionally high: 99.9% adherence within a 10-second tolerance in the first few days of the current month; Last month: 99.86%; month before: 99; 84%. Has a consistent upward trend over the last 18 months.

R. Morton commented the following: Within 5 months the public opening ceremony of the next phase 2 of Skyline from Pearl Harbor to Lagoon Drive towards the Honolulu Airport, and Kalihi  Street Transit Center is planned for September 30th at the airport location, and that the regular customer service rides will be starting on October 1st; He also added that this is a complex project, and the date is subject to change, requiring certification from 11 people, including government officials; The on time performance of Skyline for this month was 99.9%within 10 seconds; He thanked D. Sakamoto for restarting the CFADAR meetings again since the COVID epidemic.

Q&A on Skyline

C. Oshiro raised the following concerns: She had issues with Skyline regarding how inconvenience it is for the riders right now to have to catch the rail from the westside and get off at the Aloha Stadium station, and then have to transfer to a bus to continue on their destination to the airport She also asked what will be the new hours for operations in October?

R. Morton response: The operating current hours are 5:00 AM - 7:00 PM, and as of October 1st, 2025 the planned hours will be 4:00 AM - 10:30 PM to accommodate airport and Pearl Harbor employees.

G. Faligan asked the following: Will there be any sort of Sponsorship/advertising ?

R. Morton response: The sponsorship and advertising within the stations are a possibility in being looked at however, billboards are out of the question.

G. Faligan asked the following: The rail is costing a lot for Its operations and that the city is looking for additional monetary funding from the feds; She heard that the city is providing free passes to some city employees to ride the rail, and inquired if this was true?

R. Morton response: A Free Cut program for city employees to use transit for free rides is planned and will be evaluated over a year.

G. Faligan asked: Will you inform the public about this?

R. Morton response: Yes

Next agenda item is update regarding with the City’s auditor report of Skyline Americans with Disability Act (ADA) compliance

D. Sakamoto expressed the following: He participated in the city’s audit of Skyline, and asked if R. Morton could provide an update regarding with the city auditor’s report that indicated that the outside sidewalks were not being ADA Title II accessible, with Title VI in having different languages being provided, and not having accessible restrooms.

R. Morton response: DTS believes that the inside station properties are ADA compliant; Regarding with the pathway improvements a program is in place to improve those pathways at certain stations such as the Halawa station to allow to have a more direct accessible route when walking from the ADA parking area to the station; As for the off street Accessibility for bus stops DTS has an ADA improvement program for bus stops, done annually based on a priority list; The audit suggested DTS fix state highways/city streets, which is not DTS’s responsibility; As for Title VI all different languages are being provided on Skylines stations/website.

D. Sakamoto asked the following: Can you provide an update status regarding with the construction of the Pearl City Highlands pedestrian walkway bridge?

R. Morton response: The design for a pedestrian bridge over Kamehameha highway will begin in August 2025; The project timeline would be 1 ½ -2 years for design, and 2 years construction with an estimated completion time in 2029; The cost is approximately $40 million, with 80% being federal funded ($32 million) and a 20% city match.

Next agenda item: Update regarding with Federal Transit Administration (FTA)review report:

K. Lawas reported the following: Still no update from the FTA or from their consultant regarding with TheHandi-Van reviews since February 2025; The city is awaiting scheduling of the exit conference for the actual review.

D. Sakamoto Asked the following: When was the last time that DTS has done an FTA review for TheHandi-Van?

K. Lawas response: It was in 2010.

Next agenda item: Fee increases for TheBus and TheHandi-Van

R. Morton reported the following: The Honolulu Rate Commission proposed a modest fare increases, effective January 1, 2026, and currently under review by the Administration and City Council; Proposed Increases for adult monthly cap is $80to $90; Youth monthly cap is $40 to $45; Reduced single fare ride (reduced fare riders) is $1.25 to $1.50; Reduced daily fare cap (reduced fare riders) is $3.00 to $3.75; Reduced fare annual pass: $45 to $50; 25-cent charge for cash users on TheBus, and being waived if you are using the HOLO card; Handi-Van fare is $2.25 to $2.50 (low-income Handi-Van fares remain $2.00 on TheBus); 7-day pass: $35 to $40; The director has the authority to set fares for special events (currently fixed at $6); Low-Income Fares to propose to eliminate the $1.5 million cap on low-income fares; Current use results in $450,000-$500,000 in lost fare revenue annually.

Q&A on Fee Increases

E. Soderholm asked the following: What is the percentage of subsidies for the last year for Handi-Van, TheBus, and Skyline?

J. Morton response: TheBus recovery rate goal is 25%, and is currently around 13%; TheHandi-Van is 97% city funded, and 3% funded by the riders; Skyline is similar to Handi-Van, and that Skyline is currently viewed as a demonstration project right now and eventually to have the riders to go from the westside to downtown, and eventually to Waikiki that will take a few years to do.

E. Soderholm asked the following: Is there an update on your plans to explore in using Medicaid funding to provide subsidies for TheHandi-Van rides? And is the new federal administration okay with it?

J. Morton response: so far there hasn’t been any major changes with that yet, and explained that Medicaid provider services, which consist of two types of trips such as those riders on Medicaid to go to their doctor appointments, and are paid by the Department of Human Services through their Aloha Care or other partner providers; The second big users are those riders who use TheHandi-Van services to go to adult daycare programs that are paid by federal funding example are: Medicaid allows charging the actual cost of service $60 to $65 per trip instead of the standard $2.00, and that the consumer does not pay the higher fares due to the fact that the Department of Human Services will pay for it; He also mention that due to the unexpected new federal administration guidelines he will not propose any changes to these fares at this time until there are more details from the feds.

K. Oshiro asked the following: Can an annual pass be offered to Handi-Van riders similar to TheBus? Also, can credit card payment be used instead of HOLO?

R. Morton response: As for an annual pass for TheHandi-Van it is not being offered, because Handi-Van is a personal service with a high per-trip costs fees of $60to 70, unlike TheBus that is considered mass transportation with negligible extra cost per additional rider; Regarding with additional payments transactions it will eventually be transitioning to allow you to use your credit card on TheBus and Skyline, and as for the Holo card it can be used on Handi-Van however, not on taxis (still working to resolve in having taxi vendors to have an APP on their cell phones.

K. Lawas : She added that Handi-Van tickets can be purchased at the 611 Middle Street bus pass office or via mail.

R. Leyson commented on the following concerns: New smaller Handi-Van vehicles with rear wheelchair lift and narrow stairway posing a safety issue, and not being comfortable to ride.

R. Morton response: The newest smaller vans being procured will have side wheelchair lifts and a rear more safe accessible stairway due to a solving engineering issue; Rear wheelchair lifts are sometimes better for narrow driveways/lanes.

D. Sakamoto raised the following: At one of the Honolulu Rate Commission meetings for this year there was discussion regarding to charge a surcharge of 25 cents fee for bus riders who would pay by cash instead of HOLO card, and asked for an explanation why was this being done.

R. Morton response: The rationale is the high cost of counting cash is about $5 million annually for a cash revenue of $11 million.

Next agenda item: Update regarding with disability reduced fare

K. Lawas reported on the following: to apply for the disability reduced fare a person with a disability the FTA’s definition list would be individuals who, because of illness, age, congenital malfunction, or other incapacity or temporary or permanent disability (including who is a wheelchair user or has semiambulatorycapability), cannot use a public transportation service or a public transportation facility effectively without special facilities, planning, or design; The definition of 49 U.S.C. Section 5307(c)(1)(D) Federal Transit Administration (FTA) grant recipients are required to provide a reduced fare of no more than 50% of the peak hour fare during non-peak hours to: Seniors, Medicare card holders, persons with a disability; This is not an American with Disability Act (ADA) requirement; Alternatives if denied the appeal to DTS, low income transit fare program; Low-Income Fare Approvals Increasing for FY23: 127 approved; FY24: 1,091 approved; Current FY: 987 and counting; Application difficulty: Section 4B (diagnosis and impact on ability to use public transit), filled by medical provider, is where the most difficulties arise; Needs to be specific; Developmental disabilities: Applications needs to specify planning difficulties; Mentally challenged: Similar to developmental disabilities, the application must specify how the condition prevents transit use without assistance; Contact for application questions: Email: thebusstop@honolulu.gov or Phone: 808-768-8368.

D. Sakamoto asked the following: Has the developmental individual issues been resolved in applying for the disability reduced fare?

K. Lawas response: As she said previously the individual would have to fill out the application, and then they would be determined if they would be qualified; If they are deemed not qualified then they have the option of appealing to DTS.

P. Gartside asked: So, the individual needs to have these forms filled out by their physician to specify their impairment why they can’t use the public transportation, and is this information published anywhere that it explains it to the physician?

K. Lawas response: The application already has a section on the form that explains that.

G. Faligan commented the following: recommended that DTS to use public relations and media to better inform the public about processes, forms, and reasons for delays regarding with TheHandi-Van on picking up other riders on time especially due to traffic, weather conditions, etc.

R. Morton response: Acknowledged that OTS does have an Estimated Van Arrival (EVA) program for TheHandi-Van arrivals, and agreed that social media/videos could be improved however, he was unsure about the effectiveness of doing a TV press conference.

Next agenda item HOLO card Update

R. Morton reported: The HOLO program was implemented around 2020; The enhancements were accepted on TheHandi-Van however, it has not yet approved on contract with the provider such as TheCab and other vendors, and that they are still working with the details regarding with this matter; As for the implantation of having an Open Payments the goal is to allow direct credit card to be used on buses/rail stations, and that riders such as seniors, disabled will have to use their HOLO cards to receive the reduced fare rates; This concept of using credit cards aims to reduce issuing physical HOLO cards that cost $1.50 each to manufacture to issue to visitors; The future goal is to have a statewide system program with federal grant monies to expand the HOLO system to other county neighbor islands such as Maui, Kauai, Big Island; HOLO system experiencing Some equipment problems with retail terminals, customer service computer terminals, bus driver tablet displays primarily due to that they are becoming obsolete, and needs to be replaced; HOLO card implementation to be programmed for smartphones is scheduled for April 2026.

Next agenda item: Update regarding with U. S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Settlement:

M. Ideta reported the following: The settlement agreement between the City and County of Honolulu with DOJ regarding with TheHandi-Van phone system is Currently in the 3rd year of a 5-year agreement; currently at 95% of calls answered within 3 minutes or less.

Next agenda item: Update regarding with new Procurements of Handi-Van vehicles

G. Hieda reported the following: The current Handi-Van Fleet Size is 217 vehicles, and is projected to be increased to 226 in the next 3 years. The master agreement is to have a 3-Year Delivery of orders; In the 1st year they had a shipment of 14 Ford transit van vehicles with rear lift with 4 ambulatory seats, and a second year shipment of 15 additional vehicles with a total of 29 * Year 3: 18 Ford Transit vans with side lift in the fleet; Pre-production meeting held yesterday May 8, and the new van vehicles will have side lifts, flip bench seats, 2 single flip seats that allows 2-3 wheelchairs, and a total of 9 seats; The steps will be located on the back side of the vehicle that is similar to a regular bus with same height/width steps, a deeper well base, and with accessible handrails.

Q&A on Procurements

G. Faligan asked the following: Why are we still riding the 1400 series vans? And what procedures are made to dispose these older vehicles such as Auctioning them off?

G. Hieda response: The auctioning of older Handi-Van vehicles is handled by the Department of General Services; Regarding with the Auctioning off of the vans in the past they would look at the age of the vehicle fleet, and determine the value amount for the bid; As for the older vans the 1400 with high mileage are still being used.

E. Soderholm commented: That in the past when he would purchase these used van vehicles he would review on how high was the milage, the condition to determine the bid price that sometimes could go as high as much as $1,000.

G. Hieda commented: That Soderholm is correct, and the highest bidder will be awarded the vehicle.

G. Faligan posed the following: Raised her concerns Regarding with pictures that she has taken and shared with DTS/OTS representatives that lists the storage space on the Ford Transits with rear lift that her utility cart or example a case of bottle water are not able to fit under the single seats due to the dimension , and The items may need to be placed on the side of the isle or in the back of the vehicle; She added that one time When she was aboard this van there was one wheelchair, one walker in the back, and three riders occupying the single seats posing a difficulty in accessing and departing the vehicle due to narrow aisle spacing posing a safety concern.; She asked where does all these monies collected from the auction go to? General fund?

G. Hieda response: Yes, all of the Proceeds from the auction goes to the general fund.

K. Oshiro commented the following: Expressed that the ventilation in the Ford Transit vans with rear lift doesn’t have any top ventilation windows like previous vans; That the Air-condition (A-C) in the back is very noisy and that the air flow from the front isn’t reaching the back.

E. Soderholm response: That the rear A-C decibel sound meets the FTA standards, and that a roof vent can be opened for additional airflow if the front A/C fails.

K. Oshiro commented the following: The manifest Location on the Ford Transit vans is too low for the drivers to access it, and the telephone location is in a difficult area that she has noticed that occasionally it would fall off its cradle.

G. Faligan commented on the following: When she would call the Handi-Van cancellation line to inquire on the status of her van, the response would be that the ridership has gone up considerably and that there aren’t enough van vehicles available; Also, asked the question if the cost of purchasing Handi-Vans has skyrocketed up.

G. Hieda response: Indicated that they were in the third year of their master agreement contract, and that the next procurement is scheduled for May or June of next year.

G. Faligan asked: What about cost for replacement parts?

E. Soderholm response: The vehicle and parts costs have increased significantly due to supply chain issues that occurred during the post-COVID, and the implantation of tariffs; He also mention that the majority of these vehicles are being federally funded, and that the city’s fiscal year is different from the federal side; The City funds are on a 2-year basis.

R. Morton commented: Acknowledges that the population that uses paratransit Handi-Van has increased dramatically in impacting the services, and stated in the past during the COVID epidemic there were 7 to 8 different Handi-Van manufacturing companies however, now they have only 1 or 2 in existence; He also stated that during that period the cost of a Handi-Van vehicle went up between 50 to 70percent.

G. Faligan commented and asked: She indicated that the tax payers contribute for monies for these van vehicles, and asked what funding does the federal government provide?; She also asked with all the auction monies received from the sale of the older vans, how much of those proceeds are being contributed to the purchase of newer replacement vehicles?

R. Morton response: The auctioning older vans could bring in a revenue amount of $3,000 to 4,000 per van compared to a newer van vehicle price that cost $200,000 per vehicle; He also said that the fiscal budget for next year for transportation will be $470 million for operations budget, additional $100 million for capital budget , and revenues collected from the users is $60 million.

G. Hieda commented: The Fed’s contributions to the purchase of new van vehicles are 80%and that the city’s match portion is 20%.

G. Faligan commented and asked: The federal government has a different fiscal ending year budget compared to the cities, and asked when is the deadline to use these federal grant funds?

G. Hieda response: There is a 5-year process to use these federal grant funds, and the city funds are on a 2-year basis.

R. Leyson raised the following: Inquired if there was an interactive group of riders that can give their feedback regarding with future procurement of Handi-Van vehicles, because the newer vans being procured are not similar to the cutaway larger vans; She also suggested that a survey be created to the riders to express their views with future procurements.

G. Hieda response: The newer Ford Transits are being procured, because they fit the needs in having smaller vehicles to access narrow areas where the larger cutaways aren’t able to pick-up and drop-off riders.

E. Soderholm commented: In the past there was always a need to have these smaller van vehicles to accommodate with the narrow area places, and that has been in existence for some 34 years.

R. Morton response: As for the question posed by Ms. Leyson Regarding in having an interactive group of riders that can give their feedback regarding with future procurement of Handi-Van vehicles that CFADAR is one of the best ways to express your concerns; He also added that they are not in the business in designing the idea vehicle; Example:, For big buses that there are only 1 to 2 manufacturing companies at this time compared when before COVID there were 7 to 8 companies; He stated that Ford and Chevy companies have vehicle chassis, and that these companies have set design features to choose from.

G. Hieda commented: When they would be purchasing new Handi-Van vehicles there is an FTA guideline that they must follow referred to Buy America, which Requires a certain percentage of parts to be US-manufactured that can limit the manufacturer options.

D. Sakamoto commented: In previous van models they had issues with the first Ford versa, Chevy up lander, MV-1, and now they have these Ford Transit 2400 series that as a blind individual it is very difficult to access this vehicle especially, with narrow high boarding steps/location of grab handles/narrow isles/tight single seats/rear lift roof height posing a safety concern towards your head when boarding.

E. Soderholm commented: Delivered 14 of The Ford Transit van with the following dimensions that has a Rear Lift for year 1 with a short wheelbase with a 130 inches; Has a 4 ambulatory single seats, and 1 wheelchair that can also fit two wheelchairs as well as a driver co-pilot seat; Has a mid-higher roof; Ford company has discontinued the shorter wheelbase chassis; Year 2 there were 15 vans that had a longer body type of 18 inches with a 148-inch wheelbase, and still 4 single seats with 1 wheelchair that can also fit 2 wheelchairs with a more easily Mid-height roof.

T. Coelho commented: The next 18 Ford Transit van vehicles will have lift-up bench seats , and 2 single lift-up seats that will allow to have 2 wheelchairs.

Next agenda item: Installation regarding bike lane near the loading zone in front of the Kamamalu Building

M. Ideta response: DTS will be designating the area behind the 2 marked parking stalls outside Richards St to have Handi-Van drop-off and pick-ups , and signage was installed earlier this week.

Q&A

D. Sakamoto asked: Before installing these bike lanes, do you folks inform the general public or businesses about the changes in order to get their feedback?

R. Morton response: They always do inform the public before implementation by having public meetings.

D. Sakamoto commented: At one of the Disability Communication Access Board (DCAB) transportation meetings the subject was on their agenda regarding with the Richard St Kamamalu Building bike lane/Handi-Van posing a safety concern with drop-off/pick-up.

R. Morton response: When TheHandi-Van would be dropping off or picking up at this location it would take around 5 minutes to drop/load the rider, and that the bicyclist in the bike lane could go around TheHandi-Van to continue on.

Next agenda item: Oahu Transit Services (OTS) The Bus Reports:

S. BENNETT Paio reported the following: The monthly performance report for TheBus March 2025 the average weekday ridership was 125,761 down 0% from previous year of March 2024 period; The fiscal year-to-date ridership: 30,889,897 down 0.4% from previous year 2024; The ridership still at 33% lower than pre-COVID; The system-wide on-time performance was 71%; 35 out of 113 routes achieved >80% on-time performance; Route 151 of downtown street had <than 50% on-time performance, attributed to a driver waiting for regular passengers; Currently we have 17 in service of electric buses running; Total fleet availability is 82%; New 3-year master agreement contract for electric buses is in the process, which allows ordering buses each year without repeating the full procurement process; Projected numbers Year 1 is 4 buses, up to a total of 78 over 3 years; Then 4 years for 37; Grants for expensive charging stations are being pursued by our planning division.

E. Soderholm commented: At one point there were 5 big bus manufacturers, and then it went down to 2 companies (Gillig and New Flyer); After Proterra company went out of business then the Nova company moved to Canada, and ENC company shut down; A Chinese billionaire bought ENC, and they are bidding again for 32, 35, and 40-foot buses.

Next agenda item: Bus Detours/Upcoming Route Changes

S. BENNETT Paio reported the following: Major current detour with Kalia Street role improvements that would be affecting Routes 42, 20 expected to last another year or two; Skyline Opening Related Changes will happen in October 2025, and they are Working with the city’s DTS on bus route changes; Airport route 20 may be renumbered/re-lettered; New “W route” will have a direct shot from the airport with 6 stops, and will also have a new University Express that will go from the Airport straight to the University of Hawaii; These changes are more of a reallocation of services, not a decrease.

Next agenda item: Update Cyber Attack

J. Lemaota reported: When the cyber-attack occurred In December 2024 they were doing firewall upgrades; The Firewalls have since been updated, and that cyber security monitoring software has been deployed throughout their network; No incidents have occurred since then; Exploring in having insurance to cover lost revenue is in the process with multi-factor authentication for employees was a key requirement, and has been rolled out;

Next agenda item: Update regarding with Handi-Van

T. Coelho reported: The monthly performance Report for March 2025 in-house average weekday ridership was 2,969; The supplemental providers weekday ridership was 341, and the combined ridership was 3,310; The on-time performance was 10 minutes prior to 30 minutes after the scheduled pick-up time was at 80%; The comparative trip time was equivalent to a fixed route; 71,There were 855 trips operating in March; There were 7,200 trips were longer than 1 hour; 74% of Handi-Van trips were >than 1 hour to be completed in the same time or less than comparable fixed route times; Excessive Trip Times were greater than 1 hour of travel, & greater than 15 minutes longer than fixed route of 637 trips; Trips slower than a fixed route was <than 15 minutes; Vehicle availability was at 70%; Call center was 40,798 calls answered by reservationists; 98.99% were answered within 3 minutes, and 99.65% were answered within 5 minutes.

D. Sakamoto commented: That he was on hold for Handi-Van reservation line for more than 35 minutes.

T. Coelho response: They experienced recently a period of high staff call-outs of 7 reservationists, which impacted their call wait times

Next agenda item: Update regarding with Trapeze schedule system

T. Coelho reported: Trapeze is still a work in progress, and that test environments have been upgraded to its potential ; Still manipulating the parameter/speed settings to find a “happy medium.”

D. Sakamoto commented: Another challenging issue is that they are experiencing in reservations is doing the manual copy-pasting for each destination with specific instructions.

Next agenda item: Update Interactive Voice Response (IVR) / Estimated Van Arrival (EVA)

T. Coelho reported: the IVR and EVA system was introduced in 2015, and was tied into the Pass Trapeze system; The accuracy depends on the driver’s tablet functioning correctly to provide vehicle location for EVA; The system generally works well however, it’s not perfect;

G. Faligan asked: If the Handi-Van arrives earlier, does the driver call and report that he or she came early, because she didn’t get a call on her phone from the IVR.

T. Coelho response: Regarding with driver arrival times the Drivers were advised not to arrive more than 10 minutes early; If a driver arrives early and the passenger isn’t there, but the driver “performs” the trip in the system, IVR may not call; If the drivers do go off-route from their manifest, they are supposed to contact dispatch to update the system so that the passengers does receive the correct EVA; Usually our peak hours are at 7 AM - 4 PM with 200-350 trips per hour; Driver call-outs can necessitate reassigning trips, affecting estimated time;

G. Faligan asked: When she would call the Handi-Van cancellation #2 option, and wondering if it has decreased?

T. Coelho response: The Option 2 for the cancellation line has a call volume for cancellations is similar to reservation lines at 41,000 calls, and suggested in having a low adoption of the automated cancellation feature, because due to lack of the awareness or difficulty using it.

K. Oshiro commented the following: Yesterday, when TheHandi-Van came earlier, and asked if the driver is obligated to still wait to the scheduled pick-up time.

T. Coelho response: The drivers who are arriving early are obligated to wait until the scheduled pickup time or up to 5 minutes after

D. Sakamoto Asked: What is your back-up when the phone lines go down.

T. Coelho response: She stated that on April 24th- 25th a phone outage occurred during system maintenance/updates when a faulty switch was discovered during attempts to bring the system back online; They are exploring backup phone options with AT&T so the clients can still call the same Handi-Van phone numbers if the main lines go out.

Closing Remarks

  • Sakamoto: He thanked all attendees, including DTS, OTS representatives, the riders in-person and online. Also, special thanks to Patrick Geiser of Statewide Independent Living Council of Hawaii for assistance with the zoom platform, etc.

The next meeting tentatively scheduled for August 2025, and the date and location to be determined at a later time.

Meeting Adjourned at 11:45 AM

Minutes prepared by President, Donald Sakamoto

Back to all meetings